Talk:Project Execution Model (PEM)

From DTU ProjectLab
Revision as of 14:37, 22 September 2015 by Andkamp (talk | contribs)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Mette: Very nice topic choice that fits the requirements for the type of article. Remember the structure of a "method article". Look forward to reading more about this tool.

Reviewer 1:Andkamp

  • Describes an interesting method developed by Novo Nordisk, a nice blend between case study and method description
  • Minor English mistakes, that can be corrected through second time reading
  • Good presentation of the topics, however some minor grammar mistakes make it a little more difficult to be read
  • Nice figures, but missing captions and misplacement could provide a better outlook.
  • Main points are clear but not extensively described, in order the reader to get a better understanding of the topic.
  • No figure reference
  • More effort in inter-wiki links and hyperlinks in the text should be done
  • Better matrix of plan communication of stakeholders
  • Missing references and bibliography
  • Interesting subject with various aspects
  • Length of the article is small, as probably it is unfinished, but there is a clear enthusiasm on that subject
  • Phases makes a concrete structure of the article but the sections should be better presented in the table of contents.
  • It would be nice to see implementations on other business, as well as the pros and cons of this method
  • All in all, a nice subject that needs more effort in order to be useful and be connected with subjects such as Project Evaluation and Selection for the Formation of the Optimal Portfolio