Talk:Belbin's Team Roles - Revision history

Amani at 21:52, 25 February 2019

2019-02-25T21:52:45Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:52, 25 February 2019
Line 19:		Line 19:
	'''Quality of the summary:'''		'''Quality of the summary:'''

	Does the summary make the key focus, insights and/or contribution of the article clear?		Does the summary make the key focus, insights and/or contribution of the article clear? Not added yet

	What would you suggest to improve?-		What would you suggest to improve?-

	~~===Answer 1===~~
	~~Not added yet~~

	===Question 2 · TEXT===		===Question 2 · TEXT===
Line 43:		Line 41:
	'''Grammar and style:'''		'''Grammar and style:'''

	Is the writing free of grammatical and spelling errors? ~~Yes~~		Is the writing free of grammatical and spelling errors? There are some smaller grammar and spelling errors.

	Is the language precise without unnecessary fill words? Yes		Is the language precise without unnecessary fill words? Yes

Amani at 21:33, 25 February 2019

2019-02-25T21:33:06Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:33, 25 February 2019
Line 14:		Line 14:

	\|}		\|}

			==Feedback 1 \| Reviewer name: ''Amani Alabdullah''==
			===Question 1 · TEXT===
			'''Quality of the summary:'''

			Does the summary make the key focus, insights and/or contribution of the article clear?

			What would you suggest to improve?-

			===Answer 1===
			Not added yet

			===Question 2 · TEXT===
			'''Structure and logic of the article:'''

			Is the argument clear? Yes

			Is there a logical flow to the article? Yes

			Does one part build upon the other? Somehow

			Is the article consistent in its argument and free of contradictions? yes

			What would you suggest to improve? -


			===Question 3 · TEXT===
			'''Grammar and style:'''

			Is the writing free of grammatical and spelling errors? Yes

			Is the language precise without unnecessary fill words? Yes

			What would you suggest to improve?-


			===Question 4 · TEXT===
			'''Figures and tables:'''

			Are figures and tables clear? yes

			Do they summarize the key points of the article in a meaningful way? yes

			What would you suggest to improve? -


			===Question 5 · TEXT===
			'''Interest and relevance:'''

			Is the article of high practical and/or academic relevance? Yes

			Is it made clear in the article why / how it is relevant? Yes

			What would you suggest to improve?


			===Question 6 · TEXT===
			'''Depth of treatment:'''

			Is the article interesting for a practitioner or academic to read? Yes

			Does it make a significant contribution beyond a cursory web search? It seems that it could, once finished.

			What would you suggest to improve?-


			===Question 7 · TEXT===
			'''Annotated bibliography:'''

			Does the article properly cite and acknowledge previous work? Not yet.

			Does it briefly summarize the key references at the end of the article? Not yet.

			Is it based on empirical data instead of opinion?-

			What would you suggest to improve? When the text is finished and the corresponding references added, it will be easy to see the sources that support the article.

Raquel Valente: Created page with "==Feedback on Abstract== {| |'''Text clarity'''|| Good. |- |'''Description of the tool/theory/concept'''|| Needs to be more elaborated |- |'''Explanation of the purpose of th..."

2019-02-19T08:49:21Z

Created page with "==Feedback on Abstract== {| |'''Text clarity'''|| Good. |- |'''Description of the tool/theory/concept'''|| Needs to be more elaborated |- |'''Explanation of the purpose of th..."

New page

==Feedback on Abstract==

{|
|'''Text clarity'''|| Good.
|-
|'''Description of the tool/theory/concept'''|| Needs to be more elaborated
|-
|'''Explanation of the purpose of the article'''|| The purpose of the article is not quite clear
|-
|'''Relevance to curriculum'''|| The topic is relevant but make sure you link it with project management and state how should it contribute/be relevant. Also, it is lacking a bit of context
|-
|'''References'''|| Missing references. Here are the guidelines from DTU Library: https://www.bibliotek.dtu.dk/english/servicemenu/find/reference_management/references
|-

|}